I have been salivating to read March by Geraldine Brooks for so long given its relation to Little Women (March focuses on the father of the “little women” (Mr. March) and relates what happens to him during the period of Alcott’s book (if you recall, he is primarily absent fighting in the Civil War throughout most of Little Women)) and because March was awarded the 2006 Pulitzer Prize. Maybe my expectations were just too high, because I was disappointed in the novel.
Mr. March is fighting for the Union Army in the South. He is in his forties, could have been excused from duty, and is a pacifist but decides to join the forces as a minister. He finds himself lowered from his intellectually elite position in Concord (his home) to being a little-respected pacifist in an army full of men uninterested in philosophical discussion, as they are instead focused on surviving.
A large portion of the novel takes place at a plantation that has been seized and sold to a Northern entrepreneur who was given instructions to make the land profitable while using former slaves as paid laborers. Mr. March is given the task of educating the former slaves and their children and does have some success with this.
Eventually, Northern forces decide to no longer protect the plantation, resulting in a massacre of most of the tenants. Mr. March survives, although he is injured. He is taken to Washington, DC to heal at a Union hospital. Mrs. March is called from Concord to assist in his recovery. At this point, the novel switches point-of-view from Mr. March to Marmie (Mrs. March). We learn of Marmie’s struggles to keep the March household together during a time of war and how Mr. March had earlier squandered most of their fortune by funding the anti-slavery ideas and projects of the infamous John Brown. Marmie also has an uncontrollable temper when she witnesses injustice, a temper that Mr. March is constantly attempting to tame as it is perceived as unladylike.
During Mr. March’s recovery, both Marmie and Mr. March have to evaluate their union given their monetary problems, Marmie’s angry outbursts and Mr. March’s consequential rebukes, and the hinted relationship between Mr. March and an educated ex-slave that he had known before he met Marmie (and with whom he reconnected at the hospital). Eventually, both the Marches return to Concord and their “little women,” scarred from the war and their relationship with each other, but determined to move on.
March was well-written in parts but other sections just read false to me. I found Mr. March to be a very unsympathetic character: weak-minded, unfaithful in his mind but without the courage to truly love one woman or another, and pretentious. I did sympathize (and learn) from Mr. March’s unending feelings of guilt and his expressions of this guilt – he constantly felt shame about his past actions (or lack thereof) yet did little to change his behavior. Instead, he unceasingly whined and brooded about how he should have been a better person and how he was burdened with the knowledge that he wasn’t the upstanding person he thought he was.
The best part of the novel, and what rang true to me, were descriptions of setting. As a Northerner myself who lives in the South, Brooks’ description of the differences in environment are spot on:
I will not say that I find the landscape lovely . . . Here all is obvious, a song upon a single note. One wakes and falls asleep to a green sameness, the sun like a pale egg yolk, peering down from a white sky . . .
Spring here is not spring as we know it: the cool, wet promise of snowmelt and frozen ground yielding into mud. Here, a sudden heat falls out of the sky one day, and one breathes and moves as if deposited inside a kettle of soup. In response, vegetation shoots out of the ground with irresistible force.
This is accurate; the same green-ness is everywhere down here. I look for other colors but everything is swallowed by green; I look for changes in altitude or land formations or something to break up the monotony, but all is covered with untamed green. It is overwhelming and exhausting and one of the primary reasons I am eagerly anticipating moving back north so I can feel at home.
Rating: 















